
The San Diego Padres used to be a bottom-budget team in baseball, operating like the modern-day Guardians or Rays do — without the success. The way of operation felt like further insult to the city with the Clippers and Chargers both departing for Los Angeles.
The root in changing that was planted with the 2012 sale of the team, largely due to Peter Seidler, a part of the ownership group. The other piece of the puzzle was the 2014 hiring of A.J. Preller as general manager. The team signed Eric Hosmer in 2017 as its first huge move but the real impact was when Manny Machado signed a monster deal in 2019. Seidler would eventually become chairman in 2020 and the new age only became clearer from there.
The team instantly became one without regard for the long-term future. Young star Fernando Tatis Jr. signed a 14-year deal in 2021 and free agent Xander Bogaerts received a massive deal after 2022. The team also made one of the biggest deadline deals in sports history in 2022, trading a six-player package for superstar Juan Soto and star closer Josh Hader in another move. When Soto wouldn’t re-sign after 2023, they moved him for a package which included starting pitchers Michael King and Drew Thorpe, the latter of whom would be quickly flipped for Dylan Cease.
At some point, the need to spend and win switched from methodical chaos to seemingly an addiction to spend. Hader’s departure post-2024 led the team to send MLB number one prospect Leo De Vries in a major package for superstar closer Mason Miller at the 2025 deadline, where they’d also pick up Ryan O’Hearn and Ramón Laureano from Baltimore.
The future already looked shaky by then but has only continued to drop off, with the team trading for Robbie Ray and Casey Mize at this year’s deadline to fix a rotation which was near the bottom of the league.
None of it worked well enough. The team never advanced further than their 2022 NLCS exit, and the years have passed without a World Series title to their name.
Though Seidler passed after 2023, Preller’s habits still reflect the way Seidler allowed him to operate.
The problem is in the present-day situation of the team. The disregard for the future seems to be catching up with the friars. The structure of the team is crumbling, and the routes for escape are all risky.
King and Nick Pivetta, the top two of the rotation, will both be on the market, and while Ray and Mize didn’t perform in San Diego, they’ll also be up for grabs. The rotation of the team was already near the bottom of the league and now may get considerably worse.
Adrian Morejon and Jason Adam, two crucial parts of the Padres’ excellent bullpen, are also set to expire. First baseman Ty France will also be available for anybody following a great bounce-back in his return to San Diego. The list of additional depth players expiring is almost endless.
San Diego’s contract situation is what makes it tough to retain their talent. Bogaerts, Jackson Merrill, Tatis and Machado are all signed for a long time, with the latter three seeing a jump in salary that totals around $25 million between them.

Merrill had a shaky season, and Machado’s start to the year was abysmal. Bogaerts hasn’t been good since signing. The tendency to backload deals makes the concern in the contract situation even worse.
The August sale of the Padres at $3.9 billion makes it tough to know how Preller will be permitted to operate. But without significant assets to trade and contracts which will only get worse, he must be careful in operations this offseason. Bringing in pitching is a necessity, but any long-term deal must succeed, or the team runs the risk of making their awful contract situation worse. Building offense may come as an expense of this.
There’s an argument to be had that since the team is already headed for an awful future given their bloated contracts, Preller should go all-in with whatever’s left. While it would be tough to do with the lack of capital in the system, it’s certainly possible that the remaining amount could be sent off for whatever the team can scrounge up.
There is no ideal option for San Diego, but by now, almost every option ends in a future hindered by the current contracts of the roster. With the success of some prospects given up, specifically of CJ Abrams and James Wood in Washington following the Soto trade, one of the league’s greatest “what-ifs” remains what would’ve happened if San Diego held onto their young talent just a little longer.
As with all teams, every confusing situation always has one main and undeniable takeaway. For the San Diego Padres, that takeaway is that when you disregard the future, it can come back to bite you, no matter how you handled the present. The city of San Diego has had its fun, but the writing may already be on the wall for what’s to come.

