
All Secretary of State Marco Rubio had to do was make a normal historical comparison.
Last Friday, Rubio was speaking to the Federalist Society’s National Lawyers Convention — a solidly conservative event (in the sense that the attendees prefer to take hard-won rights away through legal channels rather than brute force). He could have harkened back to a quote from Lincoln or Washington, both solidly American heroes. Instead, he chose a much stranger and far more revealing comparison.
Discussing the International Criminal Court, Rubio remarked, “If they’re foolish enough to try to enforce their paper decrees on Americans, our answer will probably be the same as the Roman general, Pompey, when he said to those who were trying to invoke their cities’ charters against his legions. He said, ‘Stop quoting laws to men with swords.’” The comparison demonstrates a fundamental tenet of this administration; might is all that matters, and the law is subordinate to violence.
Pompey was indeed a famous (or infamous) general, and he gained prominence in the Late Roman Republic. He was a man forged in the convulsions of a rapidly disintegrating political system. And he was horrifically ruthless.
In an age of extreme violence and the breakdown of law, Pompey was no different and often surpassed his contemporaries with his cruelty. As an adolescent, He was known as the “Butcher Boy” (adulescentulus carnifex) of Rome for eliminating opponents of Sulla’s regime (himself a leader inclined to ruthlessness). Does that sound like a figure an official in a democratic government should be quoting?
Apparently, Secretary of War Pete Hegseth thought so. He affirmed Rubio’s words in a post on X, saying, “Stop quoting laws to MEN WITH SWORDS.”
In fairness to Hegseth and Rubio, Pompey’s quote actually tracks well with their vision of American power on the international stage. They view international law as weak, flimsy and unimportant. This is amplified by their calculus that the U.S. military and political apparatus is what calls the shots for the rest of the world.

The Trump administration’s contempt for the ICC fits into this broader context of the “might makes right” outlook. Over the past two years, the U.S. has put sanctions on the ICC, curbing its ability to function. The ICC’s mission is to prosecute individuals for crimes against humanity, especially when those individuals have not been held accountable by the law otherwise. It has 125 member states, but the U.S. is pointedly not one of them, and American leaders often argue that the ICC has no jurisdiction over the country’s activities. The sanctions, however, have added a new dimension to the rift between the U.S. and the ICC.
It’s not hard to see why the U.S. might dislike an international body that seeks to impose justice for terrible actions. In just the 21st century, America has been accused of perpetrating war crimes in several countries, such as Iraq, Afghanistan and most recently Iran. Given how much power the U.S. holds, it’s much easier to ignore international law and get away with it. This thinking also extends to U.S. allies, including Israel, which itself has been accused of genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity. It is, tellingly, also not a party to the ICC and doesn’t recognize its jurisdiction.
The “might makes right” approach seems to be working for the U.S. — for now. But taking a look at history, especially in Pompey’s case, provides a warning for the viability of this philosophy.

For years, Pompey was at the top of the Roman Republic, and therefore its vast sphere of influence. He had the power to determine the course of events. He considered himself so esteemed that he had the term “Magnus” attached to his name, christening himself Pompey the Great (in the spirit of Alexander the Great, who Pompey tried very hard to emulate). There was no ICC at that time, of course, but Pompey would have ignored it anyway. The customs of ancient warfare meant that whoever was in charge could do what they wished to the conquered.
But the principles of “might makes right” eventually became his undoing. He was surpassed by someone with even greater power and influence — a guy named Julius Caesar, who you may have heard of. Caesar defeated Pompey and his forces at the Battle of Pharsalus in 48 BC, after which Pompey tried to seek asylum in Egypt and was promptly murdered as soon as he got there.
The lesson to take from this 2000-year-old example is that power is fleeting. Basing justifications of your actions on the fact that you have a more powerful army is flimsy logic indeed, and it’s not how a democracy should think. The law is supposed to transcend power, not be in its thrall.
Might doesn’t make right, and swords shouldn’t outweigh the pen.

