Friday, November 20, 2026
Centered Divider Line
HomeSportsBrayden’s Breakdown: What you need to know about the 2027 MLB Hall...

Brayden’s Breakdown: What you need to know about the 2027 MLB Hall of Fame Ballot 

Former MLB player, Buster Posey, runs the bases.
American baseball executive and former professional baseball catcher Buster Posey. Posey was a 2012 NL MVP and played all 12 of his professional seasons with the San Francisco Giants, accumulating 1,500 career hits and 158 home runs while being a premier backstop. Photo courtesy of Buster Posey/@busterposey on Instagram.

The 2026 MLB Hall of Fame class was the year of the outfielders as Carlos Beltran and Andruw Jones entered baseball immortality. This year, however, it is a tossup whether we will see anyone elected in 2027. 

To be elected to Cooperstown, a player must receive 75% of the votes. All other players must receive at least 5% of votes to stay on the ballot for next year. 

The 2027 ballot was released on Monday. The packed ballot consists of 13 returners and 14 newcomers, headlined by a former MVP whose chances have increased with voting standards changing as the game continues to evolve.  

Read up on some of the most highly touted candidates before the Baseball Writers Association of America votes are announced on January 19.  

Potential first ballot: Buster Posey 

Buster Posey enters his first year on the Hall of Fame ballot with an extremely interesting case. The 2012 NL MVP played all 12 of his professional seasons with the San Francisco Giants, accumulating 1,500 career hits and 158 home runs while being a premier backstop. For almost a century, these numbers would get you nowhere close to the Hall of Fame; now things have changed. Joe Mauer was enshrined in 2024 on his first ballot. The two players are comparable, however Mauer had more than 2,000 hits, an unwritten standard in Hall of Fame voting. To help Posey’s case, Jones got in last year with 1,933 hits. Yes, Jones hit 434 home runs and was one of the best defensive outfielders of his time, but Posey’s other accolades are nothing to scoff at.

Posey was named an All-Star seven times, was a five-time Silver Slugger, won the National League batting title hitting .336 in 2012, won a Gold Glove while in competition against the likes of Yadier Molina and was the starting catcher for the Giants three World Series victories in the early 2010s. Posey may not be selected in his first year on the ballot, but the catcher should be a good reference point about where voters’ thoughts lie about modern day baseball.  

Continuing to rise: Chase Utley and Felix Hernandez 

Both Chase Utley and Felix Hernandez saw their voting percentage rise by 19% or more on last year’s ballot. Utley went from 39.8% to 59.1% with the possibility of enshrinement this year thanks to a less competitive ballot. Hernandez went from 20.6% to 46.1% in year two on the ballot. 

Utley was one of the best middle infielders of the late 2000’s as he and fellow HOF nominee Jimmy Rollins racked up accolades while leading the Philadelphia Phillies to a 2008 World Series win. The second baseman was a six-time All-Star and won four consecutive Silver Sluggers from 2006-2009. His 64.6 WAR helps his case, but we must once again look at the 1,885 hits that he collected and wonder what the voters will think about a player with sub 2,000 hits on the 2027 ballot. 

Hernandez was a work horse for the Seattle Mariners for 15 years. King Felix threw 2,729.2 innings, including eight straight 200+ inning seasons. The righty won 169 games and struck out 2,524 career batters. His end of career statistics does not bode well for his chances, but his accolades prior to 2016 are eye opening. Hernandez won the 2010 AL Cy Young and finished top four in voting for the award four times. He was a six-time All-Star and won the ERA title twice, including sporting an ERA of 2.14 in 2014. Hernandez remains the premiere pitcher on the ballot and is on his way to induction in the coming years.  

Scandalized players:  

It is the last chance for Omar Vizquel on the modern era ballot. The infielder was gaining votes at a good pace for the first few years before news stories about his character diminished his stock. He is going to need the biggest gain in votes ever in 2027. 

Andy Pettitte is in his ninth year on the ballot and received 48.5% of votes last year, a staggering increase from 27.9% in 2025. The five-time World Series champ is regarded as one of the best postseason pitchers ever. He was named the 2001 ALCS MVP after he led the New York Yankees in knocking off the historic 116-win Mariners team. The only smudge on his resume is his admittance to using HGH to recover from an injury in 2002. This was before the MLB started suspending players for drug use, and the fact that Pettitte came clean about his usage might get him a spot in Cooperstown over the next two years.  

Former MLB player, Jon Lester, pitching for the Washington Nationals.
Former American professional baseball pitcher, Jon Lester. Lester played in the Major Baseball League for the Boston Red Sox, Oakland Athletics, Chicago Cubs, Washington Nationals and St. Louis Cardinals. Photo courtesy of the Associated Press.

Then there is Alex Rodriguez. One of the most famous baseball players ever received 40% of the vote in his fifth year on the ballot. He had been hanging in the 30% range for years and finally made it up to 40% in 2026. His 162-game suspension for PED usage after previously denying the claim is the longest suspension ever handed down by the MLB. His three MVP awards and 696 home runs will be a conversation for years to come regarding the Hall of Fame and its “Character Clause.”  

Another notable newcomer: Jon Lester 

Jon Lester has a chance to go over the 5% threshold and remain on the ballot as his case for Cooperstown is interesting. The southpaw won three World Series and was the 2016 NLCS MVP with the Chicago Cubs. He was a five-time All-Star with the Cubs and the Red Sox while winning 200 career games, a rare feat in modern baseball. Cole Hamels notched 23.8% of the votes in his first year on the ballot. With similar statistics to Hamels, Lester could get some momentum on the ballot, especially with the rise of Hernandez.  

Rounding out the other 12 newcomers are Jake Arrieta, Jay Bruce, Asdrubal Cabrera, Starlin Castro, Wade Davis, Brett Gardner, Andrew Miller, Pablo Sandoval, Ervin Santana, Kyle Seager, Joakim Soria and Ryan Zimmerman.  

LEAVE A REPLY

Featured